A Review of Micah P. Hinson and the Gospel of Progress
B. Renner

Overcoat Recordings oc26: 2005

When Van Morrison issued Astral Weeks -- his first real solo album -- more than 35 years ago, he was not an unknown quantity. The band Them, for which he sang and composed, had been successful with singles like "Here Comes the Night," "Mystic Eyes" and "Gloria" (which Morrison wrote, though the U.S. hit was the cover version by the Shadows of Knight). Morrison has auspiciously begun his post-Them career with the heartfelt and energetic "Brown-Eyed Girl," still an oldies radio staple. But all of these songs were based in a masterful rhythm and blues style. Astral Weeks was something else entirely, melding jazz and folk flavors with Morrison's R&B tendencies, and powered by longer songs -- "Madame George" neared ten minutes -- which spiraled outward and upward in a repetitive frame apparently designed to induce trance-like feelings in the listener (and perhaps in Morrison himself) and akin -- in structure if not sensation -- to Dylan compositions like "Desolation Row," perhaps with an undergirding of Ray Charles's "What'd I Say" for good measure. Those few listeners who heard Astral Weeks when it was new -- it was not initially popular -- must have wondered where Morrison could go from there. A follow-up in the same style would likely seem derivative or even formulaic, and yet one wouldn't expect a musician who had come close to creating a new template for pop music to simply return to his old ways. Listening to Micah P. Hinson's first release, Micah P. Hinson and the Gospel of Progress, I suspect I feel something like Morrison's early fans must have.
Hinson, to be sure, is not a known quantity. Listening to his debut CD, I cannot compare it to his earlier work --this is the early work -- but it is work so distinctive that one feels both that is must inaugurate a significant new career and than it cannot, that Hinson cannot surprise us like this again. A cursory listen will not reveal what is happening on . . . and the Gospel of Progress. One will note Hinson's attractive voice, somewhat husky and battered -- though not nearly as far gone as Tom Wait's or Leonard Cohen's -- and lower than that of most pop singers. The unfussy and even somewhat old-fashioned instrumentation will recall that of other low-fi artists, though it is immediately apparent that Hinson writes better tunes than all but a very few of his peers. These melodies are both immediately likeable and capable even so of growing on the listener -- a difficult trick to pull. Repeated listenings make it clear how oddly constructed these songs are as verbal compositions. Rather than following the verse-chorus-verse pattern we normally hear, Hinson has already mastered, in a number of these songs, something much more basic and unlikely. Like the lyric poet who captures in a quatrain what a less gifted writer needs six pages to express, Hinson offers merely a few lines, repeated with tonal variation and perhaps the altering of a word or two over an increasingly developed musical accompaniment to create the tension ordinarily built with a climaxing verbal line. The lyric of "Close Your Eyes", the opening track, goes as follows --

And close your eyes
And don't you make a sound
There's no worries now
And close your eyes
And don't you make a sound
There's no worries now
There's no one else around
To hear you cry yourself asleep
Again tonight.

The delicate, dreamy synthesizers which begin the performance join with the first few lines, and Hinson's soft and sympathetic singing, to lull the listener into thinking she is hearing a lovely -- and not at all silly -- lullaby. But then the verse ends with its twist, the reason there's no need to cry: because no one will hear it anyway. The music builds, adding affecting, not entirely cliched strings and a dueting female vocalist in the second run-through of the lyrics, before breaking into full electric fury with a sharp and feedback-laden guitar figure and the third, full-throated singing of the lyrics. The song has no chorus, and the lyrics and tune could be performed completely in about 30 seconds, but Hinson's vocal control and his effective arrangement make of that kernel a three-minute pop masterpiece that is as subversive in its deformation of pop conventions as were the early Cars records, though to entirely different effect.
"Patience," which begins with strummed acoustic guitar and almost lush piano, contains only 8 lyric lines -- one of which contains only the words "This now" -- repeated with the occasional variation of a single word or the ordering of lines as drums, organ and bass augment the instrumentation and as Hinson's anger grows -- because, undercutting the title, he is in fact "running out of patience". Other songs -- perhaps most notably "Beneath the Rose" -- seem more conventional at first because their arrangements give the appearance that the repeated lyrics are following the older patterns, even if they are not. But what is strikingly obvious, even here, is that Hinson has all the goods -- not simply the skills to write a tune which is new and yet sounds as classic the Carter Family's "The Cannonball" or "East Virginia Blues", but also the musical taste and sensibility to create settings which are perfectly balanced, neither lush nor skeletally lean, neither over-the-top radio productions nor merely tasteful reproductions of someone else's past glories. It may be that no one but Tom Rapp and Suzzy Roche writes songs as gorgeous as Hinson's. Acoustic and electric instruments work together and against each other; a high-keyed tinkling piano highlight slips in and out of a track before it becomes sugary; and through it all, Hinson's roughed-up voice keeps even a line full of feeling from feeling sentimental.
I am immensely heartened and encouraged -- perhaps especially in the miserable state in which my country finds itself -- to have my copy of . . . and the Gospel of Progress. Whether or not Hinson is ever able to move forward from his astonishing debut is not the issue: its excellence is. And when, in "Caught In Between," Hinson sings jubilantly, "I don't owe you all anything at all," we can hope that that very stubborn sense of individuality will carry him as far as -- or even farther than -- an equal sense has taken Van Morrison.

Lyrics copyright by BMG Music Publishing.

MicahPHinson.com